Creative Commons Licensing

 

U.S. Copyright law dictates that each creator of a work owns the copyright to that work, meaning that all rights are reserved. That sounds great on the surface.

What happens if a creator wants to share work with others and even wants to give others some rights to that work?

Many creators want to share their works and the internet has made that desire fulfillable. However, U.S. copyright is "one size fits all". It maintains that creators own all the rights. Creative Commons recognizes this tenson and works to provide a way to comply with copyright law AND share works.

 

Copyright History

Creative Commons

An Organization, Licenses and Movement

In 1998, the Copyright Term Extension Act (CTEA) was enacted. It was originally called the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act, but you may remember it being called the Mickey Mouse Protection Act because it was enacted just before Disney's Steamboat Willie was to enter into the public domain.

The CTEA extended the copyright for every work for an additional 20 years, including works that were already produced. This means that now, copyright gives all rights to the creators of works for the creator's entire lifetime and then 70 after that. When that period ends, then a work enters the public domain.
Lawrence Lessig, the eventual founder of Creative Commons, then a law professor at Stanford, thought CTEA was unconstitutional and unduly restrictive. He brought a suit with Plaintiff Eric Eldred that went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. On October 11, 2001, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on Eldred vs. Ashcroft in favor of the Defendant and CTEA remained intact.

This motivated Lawrence Lessig to create a non-profit organization that helps to give alternatives to creators that want to share their work with others and allow others to remix and reuse their works while still complying with U.S. copyright laws. In this way, Creative Commons helps creators live in the modern world optimizing the sharing power of the internet to have more options with their copyrights other than "all rights reserved".
Many others believe in the mission of Creative Commons. Since its birth in 2001, Creative Commons is not only an organization that stewards copyright licenses, it has also become a movement to continue the work of giving choice to creators in dictating who and how one can use their works. A creator can add a license from Creative Commons, like over two billion people have already done. A person can go to Creative Commons to obtain information about copyright law and how to be trained on how to use Creative Commons licenses.

Those that have a passion for the mission of Creative Commons can also partake in the movement. Creative Commons has over 700 members with 45 chapters throughout the world. Open Education, Open GLAM (Galleries, Libraries, Archives and Museums). The Creative Commons Global Network (CCGN) grows by the day.

 

There are four characteristics that are applied to Creative Commons Licenses:

 

Creative Commons Attribution icon: person with a circle around

BY

Attributed By

This icon indicates the license is attributed by Creative Commons.  All Creative Commons licenses carry this attribution.

Creative Commons ShareAlike icon: curved arrow with a circle around

SA

Share Alike

This icon indicates the user must redistribute the creator's work under the same license in which the creator attributed it.  3 licenses carry this characteristic.

Creative Commons NonDeriv (Derivative) icon: an equal sign with a circle around

ND

Non Derivative

This icon indicates the user is not allowed to make changes or adapt the creator's work and then redistribute that work. 2 licenses carry this characteristic.

Creative Commons NonCommercial icon: a dollar sign with a slash through it with a circle around

NC

Non Commercial

This icon indicates the user is not allowed to use the work for commercial purposes.  2 licenses carry this characteristic.

 

There are six common types of licenses available.

 

Creative Commons Attribution license

CC BY

This means:
Creative Commons By Attribution

What can you do with this license?

What: This license allows you to give permission to others to share and adapt: copy, redistribute, remix, adapt and build upon your work.

Who: Any user, including commercial entities, can use your work.

Users must:
  • Give credit to you for the original creation
  • Post a link to the CC license
  • Note if adaptions to the original work were made
  • NOT suggest you endorse the newly adapted work
  • NOT apply additional restrictions to the license

NOTE: This license is recommended if you want to maximize the dissemination of your work as it is the "most accommodating of licenses offered".

Creative Commons Attribution- Share Alike license

CC BY-SA

This means:
Creative Commons By Attribution - Share Alike

What can you do with this license?

What: This allows you to give permission to others to share and adapt: copy, redistribute, remix, adapt and build upon your work.

Who: Any user, including commercial entities, can use your work.

Users must:
  • Give credit to you for the original creation
  • Post a link to the CC license
  • Note if adaptions to the original work were made
  • License the new creation with this exact license
  • NOT suggest you endorse the newly adapted work
  • NOT apply additional restrictions to the license
Creative Commons Attribution-NonDeriv license

CC BY-ND

This means:
Creative Commons By Attribution - NoDerivs (Derivatives)

What can you do with this license?

What: This allows you to give permission to others to share: copy, redistribute your work.

Who: Any user, including commercial entities, can use your work.

Users must:
  • Give credit to you for the original creation
  • Post a link to the CC license
  • NOT distribute your work if it was adapted by the user
  • NOT suggest you endorse the newly adapted work
  • NOT apply additional restrictions to the license
Creative Commons Attribution - NonCommercial license

CC BY-NC

This means:
Creative Common By Attribution - NonCommercial

What can you do with this license?

What: This allows you to give permission to others to share and adapt: copy, redistribute, remix, adapt and build upon your work.

Who: Any user can use your work, except for commercial purposes.

Users must:
  • Give credit to you for the original creation
  • Post a link to the CC license
  • Note if adaptions to the original work were made
  • NOT use your work for commercial purposes
  • NOT suggest you endorse the newly adapted work
  • NOT apply additional restrictions to the license
Creative Commons Attribution - NonCommercial -ShareAlike license

CC BY-NC-SA

This means:
Creative Commons By Attribution - NonCommerical - ShareAlike

What can you do with this license?

What: This allows you to give permission to others to share and adapt: copy, redistribute, remix, adapt and build upon your work.

Who: Any user can use your work, except for commercial purposes.

Users must:
  • Give credit to you for the original creation
  • Post a link to the CC license
  • Note if adaptions to the original work were made
  • NOT use your work for commercial purposes
  • License the new creation with this exact license
  • NOT suggest you endorse the newly adapted work
  • NOT apply additional restrictions to the license
Creative Commons Attribution - NonCommercial -NonDerive license

CC BY-NC-ND

This means:
Creative Commons By Attribution - NonCommercial - NoDerivs (Derivatives)

What can you do with this license?

What: This allows you to give permission to others to share: copy, redistribute your work.

Who: Any user can use your work, except for commercial purposes.

Users must:
  • Give credit to you for the original creation
  • Post a link to the CC license
  • NOT distribute your work if it was adapted by the user
  • NOT use your work for commercial purposes
  • NOT suggest you endorse the newly adapted work
  • NOT apply additional restrictions to the license

NOTE: This license is considered the most restrictive of the CC licenses.



What are the exceptions and limitations of Creative Commons licenses?



Any exception or limitation within U.S. copyright law also apply to Creative Commons licenses.

And, as such, the licenses only apply to U.S. copyright law and do not cover such things as patents and trademarks.

Copyright law directs who can copy and distribute the copies of works. That's it. If you aren't copying a work, your action isn't covered by copyright law. In turn, if you don't copy and distribute that work, then your action is not covered under copyright law.

No law can prevent a person from reading, watching or otherwise consuming work that was previously copied and distributed. It only provides rules for copying and disseminating created works.

 

Three Layers of a Creative Commons License

Built into the description of the six types of licenses above, are the three layers of all Creative Commons Licenses.

 

Creative Commons image illustrating the three layers in a stack with dotted lines connecting each layer symbolizing that the layers are distrinct, but built on top of each other

Image Title: Three "Layers" of Licenses.  

Image Source: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/

Image Link to License:  https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

 

The Legal Code

Layer 1:
The foundation

This layer is the one that attorneys are interested in and would use in a court case. The language describes how to legally enforce the license.

Commons Deed
(Human Readable)

Layer 2:
The common language of the legal code

This layer summarizes the legal code for those who are not attorneys. This layer describes how to use each license and the key elements of each.

Machine Readable to Technology

Layer 3:
The language of machines

Because sharing often utilizes technology, this layer provides elements that can be read by web sites, search engines, algorithms, computer software, etc. This helps a person find Creative Commons licensed works.



The Public Domain

There are two Creative Commons symbols that help users in the public domain.
Neither of these symbols are licenses, rather they serve as labels to provide information about the copyright status of works in the public domain.



Creative Commons Zero icon which features a zero with a slash through it with a circle around CC0 (CC zero) allows creators to put their work into the public domain in the greatest possible extent. This mark indicates the creator, or copyright holder, of a wok, such as a museum, is waiving all its rights over the work.
Creative Commons Public Domain mark icon which features a letter c with a slash through it with a circle around This is the public domain mark and is used to label works that are in the public domain so users are aware of the public domain status.



If you would like some help selecting the proper license for your work, please visit the Creative Commons License Chooser

 

 

References

About the licenses. (n.d.). When we share, everyone wins - Creative Commons. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/

Three "Layers" Of Licenses [Graphic Image]. (2014, June 20). Anatomy of a CC License. https://wikieducator.org/Creative_Commons_unplugged/Anatomy_of_a_CC_license

Public domain. (2016, July 6). Creative Commons. https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/public-domain/

When we share, everyone wins. (2021, May 24). Creative Commons. https://creativecommons.org/


Creative Commons License
Creative Commons Licensing is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.